The 13 Best Handmade Pet Earrings on Etsy

13 Best Handmade Pet Earrings on Etsy

If you love your pet and love to wear earrings, Etsy has got you covered. They have thousands of handmade and custom pet earrings available, but sometimes it can feel overwhelming to scroll through. With so many amazing options, how do you narrow it down?

We’re here to help.

Here are some of the best handmade pet earrings available on Etsy that make great gifts for new puppy parents, cat lovers, or an opportunity to treat yourself. Who says you can’t get yourself some gifts for dog lovers?

Note: If you make a purchase using one of our links, we will receive a small commission. Thanks!

Custom Pet Earrings

If you’re in the market for handmade pet earrings, why don’t you get some modeled after your favorite pet? Etsy sellers have a bunch of customized earrings that you can get styled after your own animal. Here are some of our favorites when it comes to customized pet earrings.

Custom Cat and Dog Earrings by HandsCreatingClay

We can’t speak highly enough of these earrings. I have a custom pair that has Aloy in one ear and Winston in the other. They’re made with clay and then hand painted by the artist to match the markings of your pet. If you like animal stud earrings, these are a must-have. She currently offers dogs and cats, but I can’t wait until she adds rabbits to the mix! These would be great dog earrings if you’re looking for new puppy gifts.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Custom Pet Earrings

Custom Engraved Portrait Earrings from MignonandMignon

If you like a more classic look for your custom pet earrings, MignonandMignon has an amazing option. You can get your pet’s portrait engraved on gold plated, silver plated, or rose gold plated studs. They’re classy and cute, giving you another great animal stud earring option to choose from, especially if silver animal earrings are your style.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Customized Pet Earrings

Custom Engraved Wooden Portrait Earrings by BrandedWoodworks

BrandedWoodworks goes the extra mile, as they create a hand drawn portrait from your reference photo that gets engraved onto wooden earrings! These are just so cute.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Customized Pet Earrings

Custom Cartoon Cat Earrings by KatnipShop

If you’re more interested in a cartoon depiction of your cat, KatnipShop gives you an amazing option for your animal stud earrings. They have a bunch of personalization options to choose from, and you get to decide what your cat will look like. If you feel like there aren’t enough options, they let you write in your request!

Handmade Pet Earrings - Customized Pet Earrings

Detailed Handmade Pet Earrings Made with Clay from PrideandPop

PrideandPop makes a detailed, handmade pet earrings that are clay sculptures of your pet’s face! They can make any type of animal you’d like. The detail on every piece is incredible. They do note that because of the immense detail, they earrings will weigh a bit on the heavier side. If you don’t mind a little extra weight, we highly recommend these beauties.

And these are great gifts for the animal lover of all species, because they don’t just do cats and dogs!

Handmade Pet Earrings - Customized Pet Earrings

Paw Print Earrings

Want something a little more subtle than wearing your pet’s portraits on your ears? No problem! People selling earrings on Etsy have a ton of great options when it comes to paw print earrings. Here are some of our faves!

Pewter Dangle Paw Earrings from PawBlessings

Want something cute and classy to show your love for all animals? These pewter dangle paw earrings from PawBlessings will look amazing with practically any outfit.

Paw Print Earrings Handmade Pet Earrings

Wooden Paw Print Studs from CraftsAtCrestwood

Want some simple studs that show off your love of animals? These small, cute, wooden paw print studs are low profile but absolutely adorable. You could easily wear these on a daily basis, as these dog paw earring would match with any style.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Paw Print Earrings

Ornate, Beaded Dangle Paw Earrings from LePetitBijouBoutique

Want something more ornate and fabulous? We recommend these beaded, dangle earrings fashioned in the design of a large paw. They’re super cute and definitely make a statement.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Dog Paw Earrings

Wooden Floral Paw Print Earrings from FreshlyPickedDsignCo

Want dangle earrings that really showcase your love of animals and nature? These laser cut wooden dangle drop earrings with paw prints and flowers have an amazing design and would look fabulous on you.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Dog Paw Earrings

Cat Earrings

Any crazy cat lady like myself needs a healthy collection of cat earrings to showcase their love of felines. Here are some of our favorites you can find on Etsy.

Laser Cut Geometric Cat Earrings from LaineMindInventions

I have a lot of earrings, so it’s a huge compliment when I say that LaineMindInventions creates some of my favorite pieces. The attention to detail on these earrings is insane, and they’re large but still lightweight. These geometric cat earrings are absolutely stunning and some of my all time favorites. Highly recommend!

Handmade Pet Earrings - Cat Earrings

Black Cat in the Moon Earrings by GiftofHeart

If you’re like me and have a love for black cats, these earrings by GiftofHeart are a must have. These black cat in the moon earrings are cut from acrylic and have a striking appearance. They have awesome witchy vibes, and would make great additions to a Halloween outfit. Personally, I would wear them all year round!

Handmade Pet Earrings - Black Cat Earrings

Freshwater Pearl Cat Earrings from SilverByFashionCat

Want something a little more subtle and classy? This shop sets freshwater pearls with a silver backing that has little cat ears that peek up over the pearl. It gives a minimalist silhouette of a cat. If you don’t look closely enough, you’ll just think they’re adorable pearl earrings.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Cat Pearl Earrings

Wooden Cat Butt Earrings from NonaRae

NonaRae also ranks highly as one of my favorite earring shops on Etsy! They make awesome fandom earrings (that I have a bunch of), but they’ve also added animal earrings as well! These laser cut wooden cat earrings are super adorable, and are great for people who prefer studs.

Handmade Pet Earrings - Cat Butt Earrings

Support Small Artists By Getting Your Pet Earrings on Etsy

We here at Creative Haven Homestead love nothing more than supporting small businesses. So if you’re in the market for some great handmade pet earrings, check out Etsy first! From cute animal earrings to personalized pet earrings, you’ll certainly find something in your style. Custom dog earrings make a great gift for a new puppy owner.

Are earrings not your style? You can still find some of the best animal lover gifts on Etsy. Always try to shop small first!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want to learn more about animals, adoption, and sustainability?

Subscribe today!